Human error? engine fault? Air India chairman urges patience amid AI171 crash theories

TAta Sons and beam republic of bharat chairman N Chandrasekaran on wed said that the ill-fated broadcast India flight AI171, which crashed in Ahmedabad on June 12 killing over 270 people, had no prior red flags, and both its engines were in good condition. Calling it an “extremely difficult situation”, he added that investigators must wait for the black box analysis to uncover the truth.An Air India flight AI171, a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner headed for London with 242 passengers including crew onboard, crashed into a medical college complex in Ahmedabad seconds after takeoff on June 12. The crash killed 241 of the 241 passengers onboard and several others on ground.“It is an extremely difficult situation where I have no words to express to console any of the families of those who died,” Chandrasekaran said, in an interview with Times Now, and extended apologies over the tragedy.“I deeply regret that this accident happened in a Tata-run airline. And I feel very sorry. All we can do is to be with the families at this time, grieve with them and we will do everything to support them at this hour and beyond,” Chandrasekaran said in a statement.Tata Sons and Air India chairman on speculationWhen asked about the possible causes of the accident and whether Air India had any initial findings, he said, “One would have to wait for the probe to conclude.” The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau is currently leading the investigation, with a high-level government-appointed committee also involved. Chandrasekaran indicated that preliminary findings could take up to a month.On the pilots' credentials, Chandrasekaran stated, “Both pilots were exceptional. Captain Sabharwal had more than 11,500 hours of flying experience, the first officer Clive (Kundar) had more than 3,400 hours of flying experience. What I hear from colleagues is that they were excellent pilots and great professionals. So, we can't jump to any conclusions. I am told by all the experts that the black box and recorders will definitely tell the story. So, we just have to wait for that.”Addressing various theories around the crash, Tata Sons' chairman said, “There are speculation about human error, speculation about airlines, speculation about engines, maintenance, all kinds.” He emphasised that the aircraft had no history of issues and provided engine details: the right engine was newly installed in March 2025, while the left engine had last been serviced in 2023 and was due for maintenance in December 2025.'DGCA notices unrelated to AI171'Responding to questions about previous show-cause notices and penalties imposed by the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), Chandrasekaran clarified that these were unrelated to the crashed aircraft. “These are different from safety issues. If there is a safety issue, there is no way the DGCA will allow us to fly,” he said.Responding to former civil aviation minister Praful Patel’s comments questioning Singapore Airlines’ silence, Chandrasekaran said, “Singapore Airlines has been a great partner... Their CEO is in constant touch with me... They have been offering all the help they can.”He also addressed concerns over Boeing’s manufacturing practices following whistleblower allegations, saying, “These are things that are being dealt with by investigative agencies in the US... We have not had any red flags in our checks.”Amid reports of a Turkish maintenance link, Chandrasekaran firmly denied it, stating, “None of them (the 33 Dreamliners) are maintained by Turkish Technic. Most of them are maintained by AIESL (AI Engineering Services Limited) or SIA Engineering Company.”Air India facing cancellations post-crashFollowing the crash, multiple Air India flights have faced delays or cancellations, sparking customer dissatisfaction. Chandrasekaran acknowledged the need for better communication, stating, “We’ve got to do a better job at communication. We have put a strategic communications team in the last three days.”He confirmed meetings with senior executives at Boeing and GE, saying, “I did connect with both Boeing and GE at the highest levels... I have asked them to check and tell us if there have been issues with any of the aircraft or engines.”The June 12 crash remains one of the deadliest in India’s aviation history.(With PTI inputs)