Quebec minister steps down day after daughter criticizes special law for doctors

societal Services regime minister Lionel Carmant is leaving his place in the fusion Avenir Québec (CAQ) government and says he will sit as an Independent.

The longtime minister announced the decision, which he called difficult and "heart-wrenching," alongside Premier François Legault on Thursday morning.

"The last few weeks have been difficult and have led me to refocus my priorities," he said in the news conference. "I am choosing my family."

He resigns as doctors across Quebec prepare a legal challenge against the province’s special law — Bill 2 — which imposes a salary structure on doctors.

Several doctors have already said they will be leaving Quebec's public health-care system and dozens have already begun applying for licenses to practise in other provinces in response to Health Minister Christian Dubé's special law.

Among the doctors considering leaving Quebec is Carmant's daughter, who is a specialist in maternal-fetal medicine. In a letter published in Le Devoir on Wednesday, Laurence Carmant said she might move elsewhere in Canada if the government does not "allow her to practise freely."

Quebec minister, Lionel Carmant, resigns as contention over doctor’s bill continues

"I will unfortunately have no other choice but to leave for another province," she wrote.

She said the system is broken and invited Dubé to rethink the health-care system as a whole, rather than "blaming individuals."

The minister did not directly comment on his daughter's letter in the news conference.

Marc Tanguay, Quebec Liberal Party health critic, said the letter published by Carmant’s daughter sends a strong message to Legault.

"She’s a super specialist, she has the right to express herself and the fact that she decided to write a letter … says a lot," he told reporters, following Carmant’s announcement. 

"As a father, I can see the stress that it put within the family relationship."

Public Security Minister Ian Lafrenière called Carmant a very good minister, friend and neighbour. 

“It’s a tough moment to be honest, but I do understand his position,” said Lafrenière Thursday. 

Québec Solidaire MNA Manon Massé, who recently announced she is stepping back from politics, says the government has lost an “excellent minister.”

"And that makes me sad because we were able to talk with him. So the CAQ, I don't know where it's going," she said.

Before politics, Carmant was a pediatric neurologist at CHU Sainte-Justine. He was elected as the member for Taillon in 2018 and served as the junior minister for health and social services from 2018 to 2022.

In his address on Thursday, he said it’s not easy to leave behind files he is passionate about. 

Legault thanked Carmant and said he is "grateful" for what he has accomplished.

---

---