Need a 'real' villain? Call Kevin O'Leary. Why the Shark Tank star shows up in Marty Supreme

Kevin O'Leary is waving his " prick" signal flag proudly this yule, but non in the path that you may be accustomed to.

In what might be the most WTF casting this year, the Canadian businessman-turned-TV-host, wannabe political leader and Trump pal features prominently in the new film Marty Supreme.

While he bills himself as Mr. Wonderful, it's his blunt on-camera personality that he's best known for. He's leaning into the a-hole label as he promotes the film, joking to Vanity Fair that it's "starting to work for me."

But how on Earth did he even wind up in the Josh Safdie-directed movie, alongside stars Timothée Chalamet and Gwyneth Paltrow?

That's what some film critics — and O'Leary critics — have been wondering.

"I was pretty stoked for this movie, but man Kevin O'Leary is just such garbage. Not sure if that's genius stunt casting, but seeing him made my frown go upside down," a Canadian Reddit user wrote on a thread titled, "Is anyone else bummed out about Kevin O'Leary being in Marty Supreme?"

The 101 on O'Leary is that the 71-year-old was born in Montreal and made a name for himself in the business world, co-founding the tech company SoftKey (later known as The Learning Company) in 1986 and selling it to Mattel 13 years later in a transaction worth as much as $4 billion.

O'Leary briefly campaigned to be leader of the Conservative Party of Canada in 2017.

He also made headlines for a 2019 boat crash in Ontario's Muskoka Region that killed two people and led to his wife, Linda O'Leary, being charged. She was found not guilty of careless operation of a vessel in 2021.

Kevin O'Leary Tells All In Dragons' Den Extended Interview

Marty Supreme tells the story of Marty Mauser (Chalamet), a 1950s-era table tennis player convinced of his destiny as a generational talent.

O'Leary, in a supporting role, plays Milton Rockwell, a wealthy impresario who takes an interest in Chalamet's Marty.

But Safdie said he needed someone in the role who could "evoke the ruthless American dream."

He told guest host Talia Schlanger that O'Leary "instantly made every line better" when they did a read-through of the script.

Although Golding wasn't a fan, other critics have seen O'Leary's casting as Rockwell as a success.

"All of O’Leary’s core characteristics are there: his political insensitivity, ruthless wheeling and dealing, and thirst for blood," wrote The Cut's Cat Zhang.

The film itself is getting generally favourable reviews — it has a 95 per cent fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes — and it's in strong contention to get a number of nominations at the upcoming Academy Awards.

And, if you're wondering, studio A24 is promoting O'Leary for Oscar consideration in the best supporting actor category. Thus far, he has not been nominated for any of the key precursor awards and he is not among the top-tier contenders, according to leading industry publications and oddsmakers.

5 best movies of 2025

O'Leary seems to want the world to know that Safdie and co-writer Ronald Bronstein were looking for a "real asshole" when they cast him, something he has recounted in interviews with The Hollywood Reporter, TMZ and others.

"I am not an asshole," he explained to Vanity Fair. "I just tell the truth, and some people don’t like it. I think maybe I’m going to become the honorary chairman of all assholes everywhere after this. And it’s a job I’m happy to take.”

According to the Cambridge Dictionary, the word is a vulgar term used to describe someone considered "stupid or unpleasant" — and that's how some people may mean it.

Other commenters on that aforementioned Reddit thread described him as "evil," a "traitor" and even went so far as to say they won't see the movie "specifically because of the casting."

In the past year, in particular, he's been a divisive figure for Canadians.

O'Leary is chummy with Donald Trump. He's spent time at the U.S. President's Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida, cheered for some MAGA policies and faced backlash for his takes on Trump's repeated comments about Canada becoming the 51st state.

O'Leary's former Dragons' Den colleague Arlene Dickinson wrote in a LinkedIn post in March that his "whole brand is bombastic theatrics — big pronouncements with few facts, flashy takes and whatever keeps the cameras rolling on him."

But it's not just his business style and political leanings that get some people's backs up.

He also made controversial comments earlier this year about Jeffrey Epstein, saying "nobody gives a poop" about the deceased sex offender who had connections to Trump, and adding of Epstein's sex trafficking victims: "Maybe they were raped, maybe they weren’t."

Even while promoting the movie, he raised some eyebrows by saying that A24 "could save millions" by using AI-generated extras instead of casting humans in background roles in films like Marty Supreme. He later said his remarks were taken out of context.

Senior Writer

---

---